« GameSetNetwork: The Best Of The Week | Main | LA Game Space Introduces Kids To Game Development »

Monday, February 1, 2010

NightSky Lookalike Pulled To Change 'Coincidence'

Trundle's release last week by Mobile Bros. was well received by iPhone users looking for a fun and free puzzle-platformer (with downloadable level packs), but it also was the source of online quarrels over whether it "ripped off" Nicalis's NightSky for WiiWare, also a puzzle-platformer with silhouetted graphics, gradient backgrounds, a serene soundtrack, a ball as the main character, and other similar elements.

Some argued that NightSky's ideas are common in many games, but others like Canabalt developer Adam Saltsman called it an obvious clone: "While there is admittedly a fine line between inspiration/homage and clones/ripoffs, this is CLEARLY the latter. ... Selling level packs based on how much people like someone else's designs is immoral and regrettable." He then called on Mobile Bros. to take down Trundle immediately.

The studio has since done just that, pulling the game from the App Store to change those similarities. "By some form of coincidence, both games decided to use a ball protagonist against shadowy levels; because of this we feel that it would be better to differentiate our character a bit more and try to eliminate any similar level elements from Trundle," Mobile Bros. commented.

The developer says it expects to have Trundle back on the App Store "quite soon." In the meantime, you can play some of Mobile Bros.'s other iPhone releases like Pachingo and Energy Harvest, which look an awful lot like Peggle and Auditorium.

Comments

BEWARE THE WRATH OF ADAM SALTSMAN

Um, both are obvious ripoffs from the vaporware indev Limbo game - http://www.limbogame.org/

Well now, in fairness, you really can't call anybody out on mimicking a PopCap game in their design. PopCap's entire fortune is built on clones of games that came before them (though obviously they've branched out since then).

But yeah, Trundle looks a whole lot like NightSky. A *whole* lot like it.

@Kizielewicz: The similarity to Limbo is in the silhouette style, which has appeared in several games and hundreds of other pieces of art before Limbo. Trundle, however, copies not only NightSky's graphical style, but its player character (a rolling ball with a glow inside), musical approach (serene and moody), and level design (some screens are near-identical).

windmills as obstacles?

ICO.


Or Don Quixote.

Stu: Windmills that you must roll up onto using your momentum and a hill/overhang combination, where in each case there are four vanes, a void in the hub, and no building beneath to put the millstones in?

pwnt

Post a comment



If you enjoy reading GameSetWatch.com, you might also want to check out these CMP Game Group sites:

Gamasutra (the 'art and business of games'.)

Game Career Guide (for student game developers.)

Indie Games (for independent game players/developers.)

Finger Gaming (news, reviews, and analysis on iPhone and iPod Touch games.)

GamerBytes (for the latest console digital download news.)

Worlds In Motion (discussing the business of online worlds.)


GameSetWatch [Twitter / RSS feed] is an alt.video game weblog from the people who run:



Copyright © 2009 Think Services