Analysis: At E3, Sony Says 'Just Wait' - But Can Consumers?
July 15, 2008 10:00 PM | Simon Carless
[Gamasutra's Christian Nutt returns from attending Sony's E3 2008 press conference to look past the announcements and analyze the trends, asking primarily - was Sony's message to consumers targeted to the now, or to the soon?]
The most important theme of Sony's press conference this year seemed to be "just wait."
That's not a good sign for a company whose next-generation platform has not yet hit its stride and which - it was revealed at the conference - will still cost $399.99 in the U.S. at year's end, albeit for an 80GB model.
While SCEA president and CEO Jack Tretton promised "a lineup that features the biggest exclusives in the industry" and reminded the audience that "as many of you have already written, 2008 is the year of the PS3," his promise that "we've just begun to scratch the surface on what we intend to deliver to consumers in the years ahead" was probably the most important message at the conference.
Recapping the PlayStation and PlayStation 2 lifespan, Tretton reminded us that big hits didn't appear on those systems until middle and later in their lives - for example, God of War II didn't hit the PS2 until nearly seven years after the system's launch. The same, it was implied, would hold true for the PlayStation 3 - but in the meantime, here's Resistance 2.
Sony does have one game it can rely on for generating goodwill in the mainstream and hardcore press like no other - and that game was used to deliver a typically staid presentation of the hard numbers to the attendees, which very much took the edge off (and served as a clever way to show the game without debuting any new features.) Yes, LittleBigPlanet was used to deliver a PowerPoint presentation in gorgeous, amusing, and clever 3D.
Tretton reminded us (with help from LBP's Sackboy) that the company has three very active platforms, with calendar 2008 sales in North America of 1.8 million for the PS3, 1.6 million for the PSP, and 1.5 million for the PS2. Tretton announced Latin American distribution for its consoles is commencing. Worldwide goals for the systems this year are 9 million PS2s, 10 million PS3s, and 15 million PSPs - showing continued confidence in the uptick the portable has seen in recent months.
Painting the PS2 as an "incubator for next-generation adoption", Tretton promised 130 titles for the system in the year and showed a video with no surprises whatsoever - relying on Madden and Tiger Woods from the perennial EA Sports lineup.
The PSP video was similar, though a Resistance game, developed by Sony's Bend Studio, was revealed later. Tretton also talked up Sony's social gaming efforts, showing Buzz titles for every Sony platform and plenty of Singstar titles for the PS2.
Earlier, Alex Evans, co-founder of LittleBigPlanet developer Media Molecule, expressed his happiness that his game is appreciated by a "wide range of people" and "what I find amazing is that this concept of creative gaming, people have just really got it."
Fortunately, LBP is not the only effort Sony is making to reach out to creative, networked gamers. Tretton revealed that there have been 180 million downloads on the PlayStation network since November 2006, across 10 million accounts.
Snarkily, after announcing a new download-only Ratchet & Clank game for PSN, Tretton remarked "We're not interested in filling up our store with titles nobody wants to play s owe can say we have the most games." Gran Turismo TV, a video-on-demand service for motorsports video which operates from within Gran Turismo 5 Prologue was unveiled. With licensed content from around the world, including Japanese and British programming (BBC's Top Gear), it appears to offer an almost unrealistically hardcore channel for race fans.
Basic promises for the eventual release of PlayStation Home came next - with nothing new or significant about the platform shown. Tretton said, "I absolutely guarantee that when PlayStation Home is available through our extended beta program, your patience will be more than rewarded." I'm still optimistic about Home, but waiting to find out what it will really offer is wearing somewhat thin.
Tretton next announced and demoed the PSN video download service with the help of Eric Lempel, PSN director of operations. It does look easy to use and impressive, and should help stave off the "Netflix advantage" Microsoft is enjoying, per its announcement yesterday.
Next, Sony presented a video reel of developers talking up developing on its PlayStation 3 system - to try and instill some sort of confidence in the press (and perhaps, other developers) that the platform has unique features, has matured its tech, has gained the necessary audience, and offers a future that is worth participating in.
Points touched on included that it has much untapped power, that programmers can really use the complicated SPU architecture properly now, and the system was packed with "forward-looking" features "including disk space", according to Dominic Guay, tech director at Ubisoft Montreal, who joined others from EA Tiburon and Bethesda in praise of the machine.
A CG God of War III teaser was shown, but the final unveil was Zipper Interactive's MAG: Massive Action Game (pictured), which is the owner of both one of the worst titles in the history of games and impressive technology that will allow 256 players to join together to fight massive battles - presumably, anyway, as the trailer seemed to be target footage and not show gameplay-specific action.
Andy Beaudoin, lead designer at Zipper, promised that "It's a real workout for even the PS3 architecture - it's not remotely possible anywhere else... there's nothing like it on the market today."
Tretton summed it up like this. Having earlier recalled that we are now reaching the 15 year anniversary of the fateful meeting where the original PlayStation was greenlit at Sony, "If this is what year two of the PS3 lifecycle looks like, imagine years three and beyond."
The problem, of course, is that imagination can only go so far in such a competitive market, and with important exclusives like Final Fantasy XIII falling by the wayside, the price of the unit not coming down fast, and sequelitis becoming a real potential problem, it's not clear if the PS3 will be able to pull out of its current trend of doing pretty well, but not well enough.
Categories:








10 Comments
Man...Sony falling on it's face at another E3. They said Home would be ready last E3. Now this E3 they said it is coming...but no date. We'll see it at next years E3 also probably...it's the next killzone 2.
PS3 is a joke. Sure they have Blu-ray but now they are pushing a video ondemand service that undercuts it's own bluray product. Bad planning by Sony.
Xbox 360 is the way to go at least for another year until Sony gets it's act together.
Gott | July 15, 2008 10:58 PM
I'm not sure what the drive of this article is - E3 is about things that are happening in the future, not the now - things like announcing a video service and rolling it out there and then (in the US) are unusual for this kind of thing - and, of the big 3, Sony was the only one to announce and deliver something on the day - something that is actually in direct juxtaposition to your headline. The only really crazy delay (noting that we're in an industry that has delays as a rule of thumb - Too Human, Alan Wake, Duke Nukem Forever anyone?) is home, which is lambasted on the one hand for not being a core service, and then painted as a key hole in Sony's plans - and it can only be one or the other, not both, as most of the gaming media seem to want to play it. In terms of games, I saw a _lot_ more for the PS3 at this year's E3, and of the Microsoft "innovations", most of them I could already play on my Wii or PS2 (no, that's not a type, Singstar and Eyetoy have been available on the PS2 for nigh-on half a decade). Of their hardcore games on show at their conference, three of the five were also coming to the PS3, something that could not be said of the Sony conference, that debuted almost entirely Playstation-platform exclusive games. And in terms of games, as a current PS3 (and PS2, Gamecube and PSP) owner, it has already delivered on a _lot_ of great entertainment. Indeed, I'd be happy defending the current PS3s lineup of games against the competitions, let alone in a year's time. The PS3 is not just for the future, it's damn good here and now (as is the 360 and, if you're a Nintendo diehard or a mini-game fan, the Wii) - but E3 is future-focussed, and so rightly looks at services that haven't yet been delivered.
Axe99 | July 18, 2008 1:44 AM
To follow up with a more direct example, I'm not 'waiting' for quality entertainment, I'm enjoying Warhawk, Motorstorm, Uncharted (played it through for the second time recently), CoD4, Civ:Rev, Oblivion, Super Stardust now, and I haven't even got around to picking up MGS4, Grid or Battlefield:BC. And it's not bad for Blu-Ray either ;).
Axe99 | July 18, 2008 1:46 AM
As someone said, E3 conferences not only talk about what's happening currently but also outline plans for the future. And besides the conference Sony had plenty of showings of other games throughout E3 as well as divulged mroe info. HOME had it's own area where press could interact with it and see new room and if you'd bothered to ask anyone, an open Beta is still scheduled for the Fall and this timeframe was announced long before E3. It's looking quite good with some cool features like RC boats and I'm sure that with more developers and advertisers and companies getting their spaces up with their unique offerings and games within HOME that it will build quite a community when it's ready to launch. Maybe next E3 will be broadcast with special rooms and trailers within HOME! There's also their recent LIFE service that's coming out later this month!
With the lineup of games Sony showed off, they certainly do have their act together! Resistence 2, LittleBigPlanet, Socom Confrontation, Ratchet and Clank Quest for Booty all exclusives, all coming out this year, not to mention games like Fallout 3 and Resident Evil 5 that are multiplatform which made up a chunk of Microsoft's conference that is also pretty much advertising games for Sony!
As well there are plenty of other games like Eternal Sonata, Valkrie of the Battlefield etc. including plenty of PSN titles and PSP and even PS2 games! And there's more to come with the likes of Persona 4 etc.
And 2009 is already looking great with titles shown off openly or in secret like Killzone 2's single and impressive multiplayer, inFAMOUS, Heavy Rain and future promises of GOW3 and MAG.
Plus there's also Leipzig and TGS coming up so you can bet they saved up a lot of things to talk about incuding more games and RPGs that everyone felt were missing from E3.
In any case, with plenty of third party and exclusive games out now like Uncharted, Ratchet and Clank Future and MGS4, and with blu-ray films as the victor in the format war, there's plenty of incentives to enjoy PS3 right now!
Johnno | July 18, 2008 2:15 AM
Yes, this article looks like a return to the past, with videogame journalists picking on anything (note: sometimes with loads of reason) in order to bash Sony.
I admit Sony's press conference wasn't astounding. There were some nice trailers and a couple of anouncements.
Still, it doesn't justify the article's idea. "Sony says just wait"?
Wait for what?
GTA4? Guitar Hero? CoD4? Rock Band? MGS4? Uncharted? Buzz? Civilization Revolution? Gran Turismo Prologue? Singstar? Warhawk?
Or is it... wait 3 more months for Little Big Planet, Star Wars Force Unleashed, Fallout 3?
Or maybe 4 more months for Dead Space, Guitar Hero WT, Motorstorm, Resistance 2, Bioshock, Prince of Persia, Tomb Raider?
I don't even have time to play the games already released!!!
Nuno | July 18, 2008 4:31 AM
I don't think the author knows the essence of E3, or what was actually announced by Sony, or maybe both. As someone else pointed out, E3 is supposed to be for future games. Sony announced plenty of both. The only thing Jack Tretton said to wait upon was Home, again a service not a game. Looking at PS3 sales, the PS3 has sold about 15 mil units as opposed to the 360's 20 mil. This despite the 360 having almost a 1 year headstart. So, yea, I think the PS3 is doing famously thank you very much. The MS conference, on the other hand wasn't that exciting for me as a consumer. I already have a PS3. I want to buy a 360. So, get me excited about the 360. MS just showed off multi-plat titles and maybe 2 exclusives. Sure, they threw a bunch of money at SE and got FF, but its also available on the PS3. Why should I buy a 360?
HC | July 18, 2008 6:27 AM
What you don't seem to understand is that E3 is for the future, and holds little for what is already coming. So they did announce a great line-up. Everyone complains that they didn't see any new games. God, you must be blind, guys! We got GoW III (announced @ E3, everyone was just expecting it), MAG (trust me, in a year, you'll want this. This is Sony's strategy. You won't want it til' its out.), and we've been progressed into future updates about DCU (though it was already in existence).
The only new game MS got was FFXIII, and we already knew it was in existence; other than the Fallout 3 shown at the presentation, which is also for PS3, and so is Rock Band 2, and most of the games shown at the show but Too Human, Gears 2, and Fable 2 (that's a lot of 2s!); but alas, we've already been shown these titles. Even the dashboard update had been announced previously.
So really, what didn't Sony show? Its got a great line-up for people who get a PS3 this Christmas, and its also showing that when people tire of the awesome line-up this year (around Late Jan; you can't play that many games and have a life at the same time), they'll have plenty more to get (I'll be getting KZ2 this Feb, how about you?) [*HINT* *HINT* its already finished, they're polishing it right now, I have the verified source!]
911 Gaming | July 18, 2008 6:57 AM
Most of the comments in here are spot on except they can all be summed up to to describe the author, XBOT.
Sony had by and far the best presser and presence, they should more stuff happening now, and I was disappointed they didn't reach further into future and show more off. I really want to see Heavy Rain especially with vague reports of how it looks so damn good(N'gai twitter feed yesterday)
Author doesn't get E3 at all and was probably floored by how good Microsoft's presser was with them blatantly copying the other companies.
Stupid Xbot, give your E3 pass to someone else next year
Makidian | July 18, 2008 7:39 AM
Actually, I agree with the author. Yes, E3 is and should be about the future, but some of those things they showed were items they showed at LAST year's E3.
To me, at least, the problem is that Sony's been making promises at E3 for the past 3 years, and we're *still* waiting.
So I don't think the author is off-base. Announcing things is fine, but announcing things just to cover up the fact that you failed to deliver on key products (LBP, Home, KZ2, WO:HD to name just a few) isn't really a true announcement; it's a distraction.
Also, announcing things with a cutscene "teaser" trailer REALLY shouldn't count as an announcement. Only 10 years ago, people didn't "announce" anything until they had playable demos on the show floors. But now they get away with showing CG trailers, 3 years before the game's release. (I'm looking at you, KZ2)
orakga | July 18, 2008 10:12 AM
to gott.... video service doesnt affect blu-ray. if you cant differentiate their difference you should stop talking all at once
annoyed | July 18, 2008 12:50 PM