[*UPDATE*: Download the original game or play the first-month challengers for the $10,000 Dobbs Challenge modding contest - enter now, contest ends June 13th!]

« GameSetMicroLinks: End Of The Week, Innit? | Main | The Limits Of Authorship In Game Development »

Tonight, Tonight, The Parish Sings Tonight

- 1UP's Jeremy Parish writes about all kinds of random stuff on his Gamespite.net personal blog, but I wanted to point to a recent post about the latest 1UP Show, currently available on GameVideos.com, in which there is apparently "...a brief West Side Story-esque musical interlude from Parish about receiving the [Super Mario Galaxy] in the mail", as Wii Fanboy notes.

These kind of shenanigans are why 1UP is my favorite major consumer game site, and what's even funnier is Parish's GameSpite-based description of the game journalism war [EDIT: Parish says 'complementary writing styles!'] that underlies the entire ethos which allows, uhh, West Side Story-style musical interludes in game videocasts: "Still, I like the idea of "Second Street Story," detailing the bitter feud between the Nets and the Sharkeys -- employees of rivals C|net and Ziff-Davis, thrust by fate into a narrow corridor of the same block in the ghettos bordering San Francisco's cutthroat financial district."

Oh yeah? "On one side of the dividing line, the Nets believe that videogames are consumer commodities and should be evaluated accordingly, without regard for individual passion or interest. On the other side, the Sharkeys are hard-livin' ruffians who see gaming as a personal, social experience to be extemporized upon from the heart. And the forbidden romance that tears them apart."

And with that, Parish dreams up some GameSpot-bating lyrics to go with the whole pastiche: "When you're a Net, You're a Net all the way, And your tone's corporate, When you write about games." He kids, abstractly, but in kidding, he speaks the truth more than he knows - at least, about the war between mechanical and inspirational game reviewing. C'mon, guys, CMP will referee your rumble next to that stupid silver sculpture!

[UPDATE: Oh yeah, and it's also worth pointing out that GameSpite Issue 1 is out, with a bunch of Gamespite forum-ites contributing interesting profiles of games from Deja Vu to Rhythm Heaven/Tengoku.]

Comments

You know, the funny thing is I don't really see it as a "war," as you term it. I suppose it's different for the people trying to secure ads and exclusives, but from my perspective the major sites are more complementary than competitive -- with the "Second Street Story" riff specifically intended as homage to how the big sites approach coverage in very different ways.

No, no, you clearly hate all other websites!

Kidding - but I think that personal reviews are so much more relevant and worthwhile than ones that attempt to say what 'the reader' would think of the game.

Especially given that 'the reader' for a lot of game review sites is not really that representative of the entire game-playing population.

Sharkeys 4 life, yo.

Post a comment



If you enjoy reading WorldsInMotion.biz, you might also want to check out these CMP Game Group sites:

Gamasutra (the 'art and business of games'.)

Game Career Guide (for student game developers.)

Games On Deck (serving mobile game developers.)

Indie Games (for independent game players/developers.)

Game Set Watch (the Group's alt.game weblog.)


Weekly Archive

GameSetWatch is an alt.video game weblog from the people who run:



Copyright © 2008 Think Services