« Viva Pinata: Crime Of A Mache Nation | Main | Establishing A Beachhead In A Crowded Genre »

Do You Want Games For Lunch?

x.jpg Sometime Joystiq columnist and VGMWatch escapee Kyle Orland pinged me about his dangerous new project, 'Games For Lunch', which seems to do - exactly what it says on the tin: "Games for Lunch is a playlog. Every day I play one game for an hour and blog about my experience. At the end, I review the game based on the only real criteria that matters to me: Do I want to keep playing?"

Sure, he gets reflexively a tad defensive in the initial FAQ, responding to the imagined slight 'This isn't really a fair way to review games' by noting: "You're right, playing a game for just an hour really isn't fair to the game as a whole. Still, I feel that with the vast majority of games, you've seen most of what the game has to offer after an hour." And you know, that's not a horrific statement. [OR IS IT?]

Anyhow, the first content post is for the Halo 3 Beta, and he echoes what I've pretty much found so far: "It occurs to me that the other people playing this game in the middle of the day probably have enough free time to put in a lot more practice than I have. Thus I rationalize yet another crappy performance."

Overall, the game gets a 'maybe' for longer-term play just because: "I can't see myself putting in the hours to actually become good enough to hold my own at multiplayer." Hey, Bungie/Microsoft, can't you create a playpen for us malco-ordinated kiddies?

Comments

Lunchtime isn't the right time for a violence heavy experience like Halo 3. I've found more relaxing persuits like Catan work better. Though H3 bored me after a few days, so I might not match the common taste.

I think there are better criteria than "Do I want to keep playing?"

I like the concept, but he shouldn't call them reviews when they're clearly not.

(also, I've played a few games that turned out to be very good the fact that I didn't particularily enjoy them after an hour, and perhaps more importantly, I've played quite a few mediocre games that I did enjoy during the first hour).

Oh please please review Twilight Princess.

"I wandered around a town for a bit and herded some goats. I found some lady's cat. Right at the end I got to beat up a training dummy. This whole game must be a postmodern commentary on how boring Hyrule is when not threatened by encroaching evil."

Post a comment



If you enjoy reading GameSetWatch.com, you might also want to check out these CMP Game Group sites:

Gamasutra (the 'art and business of games'.)

Game Career Guide (for student game developers.)

Games On Deck (serving mobile game developers.)

Indie Games (for independent game players/developers.)

GamerBytes (for the latest console digital download news.)

Worlds In Motion (discussing the business of online worlds.)


Weekly Archive

GameSetWatch is an alt.video game weblog from the people who run:



Copyright © 2008 Think Services