« Confessions Of A 30-Year-Old Gamer | Main | 'Beyond 3DO': Jag vs 3DO: Life After Death? »

Wednesday, January 17, 2007

Wazap, New Video Game Search Engine? Hang On!

- The current glut of Web 2.0-related funding for 'social media' and aggregator sites of many and ridiculous kinds hasn't extended too far into the video game biz, thus far - and that's probably good, because the last thing we need is VCs targeting the game biz with dubiously overoptimistic aspirations of Google-size greatness. However, game search engine Wazap has just announced a $7.9 million round of funding, presumably by dangling some choice game industry demographics in front of investors.

According to the WebProNews report: "Wazap is scheduled to launch in the United States in February... Vertical and niche searches are becoming all the rage, and with the video game industry ripe for takeoff in 2007, the timing for a U.S. launch of the gaming search engine couldn't be better." Hmm... you know what, I'm going to call shenanigans on this one, and here's why.

Firstly, as you guys may remember, Ziff Davis launched Gazerk last E3 - a branded game search engine with the might of editorial sites like 1UP behind it. That went just about nowhere, I'm afraid - interestingly, I just found a discussion of Gazerk and Wazap on the Search Engine Lowdown website. This doesn't augur well for Wazap, which has no such editorial sites to drive eyeballs.

And more to the point, check out this Alexa graph showing the major Wazap sites - as can be seen, it's Wazap.jp which is driving most of the traffic, and a visit to a game page on Wazap.jp reveals a site (running since 2001 or so!) that has little to do with search engines - it's much more of a GameFAQs-style site, with messageboards, cheats, and release info for each game. It's a really nice site, but 'search engine'? Nope.

However, Wazap.de, the much newer site (here's a results page for Children Of Mana) is much closer to a 'gaming search engine', with vanilla web results alongside eBay/retail store purchase links, etc. This is presumably what Wazap is intending to roll out in the States - and honestly, I don't see it making much of a splash.

So, the Search Engine Lowdown site raves: "According to eMarketer, 40% of American adults play video games (35% female, 45% male). When those percentages are converted into sheer numbers and sales, that is a staggering market to enter." No, no, no - this is missing the point. When I want to search for info about video games, I use Google. When it's about video game news, I use Google News (for formal reports) and Technorati (for less formal reports).

So, in conclusion - VC funders need to think more carefully about what they're supporting. For me (and, I believe, most people) - here's absolutely nothing specific about games that would make we want to remember to switch to a game-only search engine. Would I switch to a dog-specific search engine when looking for info about my dachshund? Nope.

What Wazap needs is its Japanese site (which is smart, but has pretty much nothing to do with the horribly buzzwordy 'search') rolled out over all territories, and it needs to have done that back in, uhm, 2000 or so in order to have built up a significant community, which is the one thing money can't buy. Still, I don't imagine venture money extends to funding time reversal just yet?

Comments

hm, I read your article, checked out wazap and have to say that I don`t agree to all your points... check their "infopages": http://de.wazap.com/Katalog/Mac-PC/World+of+WarCraft+-+The+Burning+Crusade/Informationen
I haven`t seen a better aggregation of information for one game on one page... but yes, they have to further develop their search and have to implement community features...

Gazerk was a good idea that wasnt executed very well. Ziff knows publishing and gaming.. not necessarily search.

I took a look at the example you linked to, and i think that wazap has the right idea, and they're doing it in such a way that makes sense to the users. obviously, the Japanese, Chinese and German markets are different than the US markets and expectations, so I'll reserve judgement, but i think they'll do a great job.

I totally agree with you that something like this should have been done in 2000, but since it wasnt done then, are you saying it shouldnt be done now?

@ andy
community features would be essential not only to differentiate wazap, but to retain people. i'd like to see them do that.

Well, if you guys are a bit more excited about Wazap, then fair enough.

I guess what I'm saying is that I don't feel like game-specific aggregators bring much to the party, and a conventional game journalism site would never get $7.5 million in funding - so why should a 'search engine' for games get one?

good point simon...

I've read this blog for a long time and i really like it, and one of the reasons i'm excited about it is that it could be a significant potential for traffic to sites like this. exposing independent and commercial journalists, bloggers and reviewers to a wider audience. i guess that, if wazap does its job right, then it's win - win for everyone in the industry.

"What Wazap needs is its Japanese site (which is smart, but has pretty much nothing to do with the horribly buzzwordy 'search')"

search.wazap.jp, webresults combine UGC and external search results, which makes this search definitely unique. if you search on wazap.jp you jump directly on the search.wazap.jp.

Wait a minute. Wazap's video game search engine isn't a search engine at all. If you are going to have a video game search engine, you need to be able to find a game if you don't know the name. Game-Hunt (www.game-hunt.com) is a student developed project. Now *THAT* is the best video game search engine I've found.

Post a comment



If you enjoy reading GameSetWatch.com, you might also want to check out these CMP Game Group sites:

Gamasutra (the 'art and business of games'.)

Game Career Guide (for student game developers.)

Games On Deck (serving mobile game developers.)

Indie Games (for independent game players/developers.)

GamerBytes (for the latest console digital download news.)

Worlds In Motion (discussing the business of online worlds.)


Weekly Archive

GameSetWatch is an alt.video game weblog from the people who run:



Copyright © 2008 Think Services