COLUMN: 'Keyboard Bashing' - Remembering The Fate of Atlantis
August 16, 2006 8:59 AM |
['Keyboard Bashing' is a new GameSetWatch column by Tales of a Scorched Earth's Andrew Smale which discusses the history, present and future of PC gaming. This inaugural column looks lovingly at a classic LucasArts title.]
Indiana Jones and the Fate of Atlantis (1992) was the seventh LucasArts game to use the venerable SCUMM engine. It fell in between Ron Gilbert's influential The Secret of Monkey Island (1990) and adventure game fan favorite Sam and Max Hit the Road (1993). It could easily be considered among the hallmarks of adventure gaming, at the peak of LucasArts' influence on the genre.
It is also the best game I have ever played.
I can install it again as if it was the first time, and still get the same enjoyment from it. I can honestly say that it's like watching a favorite movie - but a movie that actually is as good as I remember it - and enjoying every moment spent re-solving the game's challenging but intuitive puzzles and listening to the wonderfully crafted dialogue. I'd even call the whole thing "cinematic."
In game criticism's search to find itself, the term "cinematic" is thrown around quite a bit, as if it was the only way to describe a game's presentation. Combining an appealing visual aesthetic with an engaging storyline keeps the player involved, who will return to the game simply to find out what happens next. As games approach levels of visual realism only dreamed about 10 years ago - with the hardware to produce it seemingly driving the industry - has the definition of "cinematic" changed?
It has, but only unwittingly. Back when there was nothing better to compare to, computer games were often described with the same terms they are now. But looking through my old copies of Computer Gaming World and PC Gamer is downright embarrassing to see what games the descriptor was attached to. A game can be cinematic without obsessing over excessive amounts of visual detail or immaculate sound, because it's about supplying a package.
When I first saw Raiders of the Lost Ark as a young lad, I immediately wanted to be an archaeologist. Not because I was interested in history, but because it meant I would get to travel the world searching for ancient artifacts while trying to stay one step ahead of the Bad Guys. The Fate of Atlantis recaptured this feeling. You weren't supposed to be Indy; you were following him on one of his adventures. To this day I am convinced that in the right hands, a film based on this game would feel right at home in the Indiana Jones saga - it is so in touch with the mythos.
While made up of standard adventure fare like navigating dialogue options, puzzles, and the occasional pixel hunt, each are presented to be seamless with the surrounding storyline. The opening scene involves Indy looking through the archives of Barnett College for an Atlantean artifact, which is subsequently stolen by a Nazi spy to set the game's story in motion. What follows is an introductory sequence of sorts, where Indy must get in touch with Sophia Hapgood, an old friend who will aid in the search for the truth about Atlantis. It turns out Atlantis really does exist, and its location is buried in Plato's Lost Dialogue, an ancient text that was thought a hoax. Once the Dialogue is obtained, the game presents the player with some options.
Do you partner with Sophia, and hope that she can provide some valuable insight for the remainder of the adventure? Or do you fly solo, and go against Indiana Jones tradition? Perhaps silly puzzles aren't for you, and the road to Atlantis is paved with blood and lost teeth. Each path touches on key points of the story, but take slightly different routes to get to the Lost City, some of them exposing areas only available in a particular path. Like any adventure game, you can't expect too much freedom, but the presentation of The Fate of Atlantis doesn't allow you to dwell too much on it.
The superb voice acting and the great sense of humor shared by all of LucasArts' early adventure efforts added some depth to the experience. The dialogue feels naturally constructed, and carries over well between cutscenes and when you have the option to choose what to say. The iMUSE system, which was first introduced by the version of the SCUMM engine powering this adventure, controls changes in music when the action on screen changes. The game's artwork is practical for the majority of the game - it's simply recreating the films' familiar time period. The Lost City, once found, is successfully conveyed as an ancient place that was still capable of developing technological marvels. It's all fantasy, but it's completely convincing.
Part of what made LucasArts' classic adventure games so family-friendly is that your character could never die. In The Fate of Atlantis, Indy can die. There are few ways in which this can happen, but they are situations in which death is a perfectly logical outcome. Allowing Indy to mutter "over my dead body" to his Nazi counterpart in one scene results in exactly that. Once inside Atlantis, you have to sneak by the wandering Nazi guards that have control of it. If you walk by them, it triggers a simple fist fighting mini-game that you have to win, or Indy will die. The final confrontation at the heart of Atlantis involves navigating a very intriguing amount of dialogue options, one of them resulting in Indy's death. I really felt like I had outsmarted my adversaries once I beat the game. While not essential to the story, Indy's mortality adds a sense of danger to the adventure. It's not meant to be serious, because we all know the hero isn't supposed to die. It simply mimics the nature of the films.
While the game does not chronicle the hunt for a religious artifact - the basis for every one of the films - there is still something spiritual about the quest. Sophia Hapgood is shown as a performing psychic and renowned authority on Atlantis at the beginning of the game, with her Atlantean necklace clearly her most prized possession. According to her, the necklace allows her to speak with a long dead resident of the Lost City, a talent that ends up providing a bit of assistance along the way. Sophia's belief in the power of the necklace blinds her to the truth of what really went on inside Atlantis; in a crisis of faith she realizes that there was a reason the Atlanteans didn't survive their so-called advanced civilization. Once again we are taught that some things are probably best left undisturbed.
The Fate of Atlantis provides a glimpse of what the marriage of a well-known property and good storytelling can do to a graphical adventure game's overall effectiveness. It is also an excellent example of cinematic presentation, without relying on the ultra-realistic visuals that are expected of games developed in last few years that are so arbitrarily assigned the term. Indeed, The Fate of Atlantis is an adventure game for the ages.
Categories: Column: Keyboard Bashing








12 Comments
Awesome game, and of course one of many classics from the Lucas(film)arts of that era. I liked The Last Crusade a lot too, but I think the sections where you had to run around in the castle avoiding /fighting nazis might be a little tiresome for me today. I remember The Fate of Atlantis was serialized as a comic too. It's great to see a column covering retro pc games for someone who didn't have any consoles during that time. Consoles get all the glory I tell you!
Prince Megahit | August 16, 2006 10:08 AM
You know, out of all the Lucasarts adventure games I have, and I have quite a bit, this is the only one I haven't played through to the end. I should really go back and give this game another chance. I really did like it, I guess I just got really stuck at some point...
Toad64 | August 16, 2006 2:30 PM
One of my favorites, too. It's still vivid just how enamored my brother and I as little kids were when my dad brought that game home.
whitebrice | August 16, 2006 5:12 PM
I've always loved this game. The Secret of Monkey Island will always be my favorite, but there's room for some Indy love. Hell, Last Crusade was one of the first games I remember buying after I bought my first VGA card.
Jason | August 17, 2006 10:32 AM
Nice to see it fondly remembered, it was one of my favorite games to work on. Hal and I have remained friends and continue to be interested in historically-based adventures, although I think we've learned a lot about the limitiations of the old-style adventure game in the years since Indy. For an excellent analysis by a fan of the historical influences we touched on in FOA I'd recommend looking here: http://lucasfic.mixnmojo.com/misc/indy.txt
Noah Falstein | August 18, 2006 7:56 AM
Excelent game. For those who liked it try FOTAQ (Freeware Now , downloadable here : http://www.scummvm.org/downloads.php )
There are some fans making also this remake (very good, indeed) : http://www.barnettcollege.com/index2.htm ) (i think it was already posted on GSW).
Enjoy and let good times roll :)
MarcoMR | August 18, 2006 10:27 AM
Thanks for the fascinating link, Noah.
Also - I wouldn't consider "The Fountain of Youth" a remake, Marco; rather, it seems like a totally separate game.
The "real" sequel can be found at AmberfishArts, who are picking up the story where FoA left off.
andrews | August 18, 2006 11:45 AM
It's so sad, we'll don't have the Fate of atlantis movie...
Ivy Alice | May 25, 2008 10:44 AM
Hi Folks!
Just wanted to share my new experience.
If your system fails to run due to an error corresponding to lost HAL.DLL, invalid Boot.ini or any other important system boot files you can fix this by using the XP installation CD. Just boot from your XP Setup CD and enter the Recovery Console. Then launch "attrib -H -R -S" on the C:Boot.ini file and delete it. Launch "Bootcfg /Rebuild" and then Fixboot
Cheers,
Carl
admin_papa | August 30, 2008 8:16 AM
Hello to All the Guests and Members,
My problemm: my pc worked slowly, fast reeboot and some others.
Please, help me to fix it - I need some programm, that consist info, how can I do it.
Thx,
unindCoumma
unindCoumma | November 17, 2008 11:54 PM
Gerade der Presse entnommen:
IHK Frankfurt: Betrugs-Ermittlungen gegen FOCUS wegen 0900-Faxabruf? Millionenschaden!
Die IHK Frankfurt soll aktuell gegen die Verantwortlichen des Magazins FOCUS wegen Betruges ermitteln und eine Strafanzeige vorbereiten. Sollten sich die Vorwuerfe bewahrheiten, kann dies das Aus für das Nachrichtenmagazin bedeuten, denn der Schaden soll in die Millionen gehen.
Die Abzock-Masche war einfach wie perfide: In jeder Ausgabe des FOCUS-Magazins wurden sogenannte Fax-Abrufe beworben. Der interessierte Leser konnte hier per Telefax Hintergrundinformationen zu bestimmten Themen anfordern. (Fakten auf Abruf) Dazu musste der Verbraucher eine Rufnummer tippen und am Telefax die START-Taste druecken. Die mehrseitigen Informations-Dossiers wurden dann zu Hause ausgedruckt. Zur Refinanzierung dieses Informationsangebotes nutzte FOCUS Premium-Rate-Rufnummern mit der Vorwahl einer 0900-Vorwahl.
So weit, so legal - jedoch blieben die Umsaetze der Fax-Abrufe wohl hinter den Erwartungen zurueck, denn FOCUS nutzte einen laut IHK Frankfurt illegalen Trick, um die Uebertragung in die Laenge zu ziehen und damit die durch die Telefonrechnung eingezogenen Kosten zu erhoehen: So wurde im FOCUS-Verlag eine sogenannte Faxbremse aktiviert, d.h. die Uebertragungsgeschwindigkeit der abgerufenen Faxe wurde technisch manipulativ reduziert. Bei einem Test konnte festgestellt werden, dass der Abruf von 8 nicht voll beschriebenen Seiten über FOCUS bis zu 6 Minuten dauerte. Im normalen ungedrosselten Faxversand mit einer Geschwindigkeit von heute ueblichen 33.600 Baud kann man 8 Seiten ganz normal fehlerfrei in einer Minute übertragen. Die Folge: 6-fach überhoehte Telefonkosten! Der Kunde wird entgegen der bestehenden Rechtspflicht nicht auf die verzoegerte Uebermittlung der Faxinformationen hingewiesen. Somit taeuschen die Verantwortlichen konkludent ueber die entstehenden Kosten.
Nachdem ein Verbraucher die Verantwortlichen des FOCUS bei der Staatsanwaltschaft Muenchen angezeigt hatte, zeigte diese wenig Interesse an dem Sachverhalt und stellte das Verfahren schleunigst ein. Begruendung: Der Kunde duerfe nicht mit der schnellsten Fax-Geschwindigkeit rechnen wenn in der Werbung der Faxabrufe keine genannt wird.
Moeglicherweise liegt das daran, dass man den alteingesessenen Burda-Verlag, der das Magazin FOCUS seit 1996 aus Muenchen verlegt, nicht vergraulen mag. Eventuell ist dies auch einfach mit der Ueberlastung der Strafverfolgungsbehoerden zu erklaeren. Die IHK Frankfurt, die sich dem Kampf gegen Abzocke und Betrug durch die Faxbremse verschrieben hat, will dieses Vorgehen jedenfalls nicht hinnehmen. Die IHK unter Hans-Reinhart Gruenbaum sieht diese und aehnliche Faelle als klaren Betrug und beschaeftigt in solchen Verfahren sogar einen eigenen technischen Gutachter. Ein Insider sieht hier sogar einen der groeßten Faelle von organisierter Wirtschaftskriminalitaet in Deutschland: "Da stecken doch alle unter einer Decke. Bei 600.000 woechentlich aufgelegten FOCUS-Magazinen und der zusaetzlichen Online-Werbung der FAKTEN AUF ABRUF werden damit jeden Monat Millionen verdient!“
Die Bundesnetzagentur sieht bis heute im Jahr 2011 eine Faxgeschwindigkeit von 9.600 Baud als ueblich an. Damit waere FOCUS im Recht. Ausserdem verlangt der Gesetzgeber aufgrund der verschiedenen Geschwindigkeiten der Faxgeraete und Faxstandards nur die Angabe des Minutenpreises und Seitenanzahl. Hans-Reinhart Gruenbaum und der Hausgutachter von der IHK Frankfurt jedoch widersprechen: Schon im Jahr 2000 sei eine Geschwindigkeit von 19.200 Baud ueblich gewesen. 11 Jahre spaeter haette FOCUS die Faxe mit voller und ueblicher Geschwindigkeit ausliefern muessen. Da sie dies nicht getan haben, sei dies als gewerbsmaessiger Betrug zu werten.
Die Folgen koennten die Medienlandschaft in Deutschland nachhaltig veraendern: Stellt sich heraus, dass FOCUS die Verbraucher um Millionen betrogen hat, drohen Rueckforderungen in dreistelliger Millionenhoehe. Die Staatsanwaltschaft waere sogar berechtigt, die illegal erworbenen Gewinne beim Verlag und sogar beim Vorstand persoenlich sicherzustellen. In Zeiten, in denen schon viel geringere Verfehlungen zu einem medienpolitischen Gewitter fuehren, waere dies mit Sicherheit das Aus für den FOCUS.
Damit kommt auf den Burda-Verlag, der schon im Kachelmann-Prozess eine fragwuerdige Rolle spielte, neuer juristischer Aerger zu. Und Hans-Reinhart Gruenbaum von der IHK Frankfurt hat schon einen neuen Ansatzpunkt: Selbst wenn sich herausstellen sollte, dass die Abrufe an sich legal waren, so sind die abgerufenen "Informationen" weitgehend wertlos. Wie eine Recherche bestaetigte, koennen die Inhalte der kuenstlich verlangsamten Abrufe mit einfachen Suchbegriffen in Suchmaschinen wie Google oder Yahoo gefunden werden - und zwar kostenlos. Und das, da ist sich die IHK Frankfurt und die Staatsanwaltschaft Frankfurt einig, nennt man Betrug. Die IHK Frankfurt wird den Fall im Fokus behalten.
Baudmann
Infos und Quellen:
http://www.frankfurt-main.ihk.de
http://www.bnetza.de
http://www.focus.de
http://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/tkg_2004/__66a.html
Baudmann | August 16, 2011 1:46 AM
Hi,I am new here!www.gamesetwatch.com looks so good,I think I will learn more from here!
Jonas 20 | August 22, 2011 1:34 PM