« Free Friday Freeware Indie Bonanza Fridays | Main | Unlikely Game IP Theater Presents: Archie Andrews »

Super Giana Brothers - Goomba-ing Up The Works?

ggs.gif Famed Wired.com blogger and karaoke legend Chris Kohler has penned a new 1UP feature discussing 'Retro Rip-Offs', or plagiarism in the game industry, and it's got some fun sassiness in it.

Kohler smartly points out in his intro: "This could easily be a piece on how popular, innovative games invariably spawn a succession of imitators. But not only is that rather old-hat as far as video game feature-writing is concerned, it would be a piece on genre creation, not plagiarism", going on to explain: "No, this is about serious plagiarism, the sort of copyright-infringement stuff that makes the lawyers come running."

That plagiarism includes such goodness as the classic German platformer Great Giana Sisters, absolutely nothing like Super Mario Bros, for which he notes: "There were eight worlds of four levels each. Level 1 was above ground, and the opening cluster of bricks mimicked SMB's. The first enemy was an owl that looked suspiciously like a Goomba. Level 2 was underground. Level 3 was on a series of platforms that crossed a vast chasm. Level 4 was the boss' lair. Sounding familiar?" Luckily, Great Giana Sisters has been resurrected for the GP32, Dreamcast and Windows in the form of 'Giana's Return' - but it's all very non-commercial, so they may be safe this time.

Comments

Interesting article, especially the bit about Kee Games and Atari, which came as a surprise to me (as I recently read an article where it was claimed that they really were competitors).

However, it should be mentioned that Rainbow Arts were not a small shareware outfit, like the article claims. It could also have been mentioned that Nintendo's lawyers did indeed come after Giana Sisters, and the game was subsequently pulled from the shelves (and is, as a result, pretty rare and sought after today).

I mentioned that (the 'shareware' comment being not quite right) to Monsieur Kohler already, so they may edit, I'm not sure.

Also, I think this piece was originally going to be for Official Nintendo Magazine UK, before Future nicked it from EMAP. Fun!

Post a comment



If you enjoy reading GameSetWatch.com, you might also want to check out these CMP Game Group sites:

Gamasutra (the 'art and business of games'.)

Game Career Guide (for student game developers.)

Games On Deck (serving mobile game developers.)

Indie Games (for independent game players/developers.)

GamerBytes (for the latest console digital download news.)

Worlds In Motion (discussing the business of online worlds.)


Weekly Archive

GameSetWatch is an alt.video game weblog from the people who run:



Copyright © 2008 Think Services